Ten NCAA tournament bubble teams with the most to prove
The NCAA men's basketball tournament selection committee cares as much about what a team did in November as what it does in February. But at this point, teams hoping to make the field of 68 can only control what lies ahead.
With less than six weeks until Selection Sunday, crunch time has arrived. Who's in? Who's out? Every bubble teams' fate is in the balance, and what's more, they're all interconnected, right through conference championship week.
Here's a look at 10 fringe NCAA tournament teams with the most to prove right now.
NCAA tournament bracketology: Projecting the field of 68
1. Kansas State
A signature win can make all the difference. The Wildcats got one by upsetting projected NCAA tourney No. 1 seed Oklahoma this past weekend, a victory that revived the team's postseason life. Kansas State plays in the country's highest-rated conference, which leads to a top-10 strength of schedule (SoS), to cover for a 3-7 league record. But Oklahoma is Kansas State's only top-50 win. There will be plenty of chances to get more in the Big 12. One thing the Wildcats must avoid: Losing to a bad team like TCU, who they play Feb. 16 and March 2.
2. LSU
The Tigers, led by freshman sensation Ben Simmons, are alone atop the SEC standings. And yet, their résumé stains and shortcomings nearly trump their conference supremacy. LSU only has one top-50 win, and its RPI is floating in the 70s. The biggie: Three losses to teams outside the top 100. More big wins in SEC play should secure the Tigers. Still, there's a small margin for error.
Villanova is No. 1 for first time since USA TODAY took over coaches poll
3. Clemson
There's a lot of good on the Tigers' profile. There's also a lot of bad. The good: Six top-50 wins, including Duke, Miami and Louisville. The bad? A non-conference SoS of 336 is one of the worst in the country and certainly the worst among bubble teams. Essentially, the Tigers have are hoping big wins counter that dreadful part of their résumé. The more, the merrier.
4. Saint Joseph's
The Hawks only have five losses and sport a fantastic RPI of 31. And yet, if the season ended today they'd likely miss the cut. Their best win is Princeton. Games against top-50 opponents for this team will be under a serious microscope.
5. Gonzaga
The 'Zags aren't supposed to be here. They have two All-American level players in Damantas Sabonis and Kyle Wiltjer. But because the Bulldogs didn't do themselves any favors in non-conference play and don't have their typical stranglehold on the WCC, they're in the danger zone. A non-conference clash with SMU is perhaps the most important game of any bubble team at this point.
6. Saint Mary's
Unlike Gonzaga, the Gaels don't have a chance to notch a top-50 win. But if Gonzaga does beat SMU, it would give Saint Mary's a top-50 win. That's the type of math that makes it painful to be a decent team in a mid-major conference.
7. Indiana
The Hoosiers could miss the NCAAs? Really? They were once tied for first place in the Big Ten and were playing great basketball before losing to Penn State on Saturday. But the only top-50 win on its résumé came against Notre Dame. The remaining Big Ten schedule includes Iowa twice, Michigan State, Maryland and Purdue.
8. Wisconsin
It's difficult to imagine the Badgers not in the NCAA tournament, especially following back-to-back Final Four runs. The Badgers have played well lately, but they are still digging themselves out of a hole they fell in during the early portion of the season. It's hard to erase a home loss to a Western Michigan team with a 274 RPI. There are four remaining regular season games against top-50 opponents in Big Ten play. Each will be vital for Wisconsin's NCAA hopes.
Eight teams that look like Final Four sleepers
9. Wichita State
Injuries, particularly to All-American guard Fred VanVleet, really hurt the Shockers' non-conference profile. They only have one top-50 victory, and the Valley offers no opportunity to get another. A road loss to Illinois State over the weekend is exactly what Wichita State did not need.
10. Butler
The Bulldogs were ranked fairly high in the USA TODAY Sports Coaches Poll earlier in the season. But now their résumé seems a bit bare. Butler's only top-50 win came against Purdue. There will be Big East games that could boost the Bulldogs' profile, but they must seize those opportunities. Otherwise, they're NIT-bound.
Bubble Tracker conference-by-conference breakdowns of the strength and weaknesses of borderline teams. Data as of Feb. 8. (Results/records shown are against Division I opponents only)
- Locks: N/A
- Probable: N/A
- Bubble: Connecticut, Cincinnati, Temple, Tulsa
In for now
Connecticut: 17-6 (7-3), 51 RPI, 72 SoS, 64 non-conference SoS
The good: Win vs. Texas
The bad: No bad losses to date
Out for now
Cincinnati: 17-7 (7-4), 67 RPI, 97 SoS, 157 non-conference SoS
The good: Wins vs. George Washington, VCU, UConn
The bad: Loss vs. Memphis
Temple: 14-8 (8-3), 69 RPI, 75 SoS, 182 non-conference SoS
The good: Wins vs. SMU, UConn
The bad: Losses vs. Houston, East Carolina, Memphis
Tulsa: 14-8 (6-4), 63 RPI, 63 SoS, 80 non-conference SoS
The good: Wins vs. Wichita State, UConn
The bad: Losses vs. Houston, Oral Roberts
- Locks: Virginia, North Carolina, Miami
- Probable: Notre Dame, Duke, Pittsburgh
- Bubble: Syracuse, Florida State, Clemson
In for now
Syracuse: 16-8 (6-5), 47 RPI, 37 SoS, 112 non-conference SoS
The good: Wins vs. Texas A&M, Notre Dame, St. Bonaventure, UConn
The bad: Loss vs. St. John's
Florida State: 16-7 (6-5), 38 RPI, 61 SoS, 208 non-conference SoS
The good: Wins vs. Virginia, Florida, VCU
The Bad: No bad losses to date
Clemson: 14-9 (7-4), 83 RPI, 76 SoS, 336 non-conference SoS
The good: Wins vs. Miami, Duke, Louisville, Florida State, Pittsburgh, Syracuse
The bad: Losses vs. Virginia Tech, UMass, Minnesota
- Locks: Dayton
- Probable: N/A
- Bubble: VCU, George Washington, St. Joseph's, St. Bonaventure, Davidson
In for now
VCU: 17-6 (9-1), 41 RPI, 67 SoS, 75 non-conference SoS
The good: Wins vs. St. Bonaventure, St. Joseph's
The bad: No bad losses to date
George Washington: 18-5 (7-3), 36 RPI, 104 SoS, 187 non-conference SoS
The good: Wins vs. Virginia, Seton Hall, VCU
The bad: Losses vs. DePaul, Richmond, Saint Louis
Out for now
St. Joseph's: 19-4 (6-2), 31 RPI, 84 SoS, 70 non-conference SoS
The good: No top 50 RPI wins to date
The bad: No bad losses to date
St. Bonaventure: 15-6 (7-3), 49 RPI, 82 SoS, 163 non-conference SoS
The good: Wins vs. St. Joseph's, Davidson
The bad: Losses vs. Siena, Duquesne
Davidson: 12-8 (5-5), 50 RPI, 33 SoS, 41 non-conference SoS
The good: No top-50 RPI wins to date
The bad: Loss vs. St. Louis
- Locks: Villanova, Xavier
- Probable: Providence
- Bubble: Seton Hall, Butler, Georgetown, Creighton
In for now
Seton Hall: 17-6 (7-4), 35 RPI, 68 SoS, 237 non-conference SoS
The good: Wins vs. Wichita State, Providence
The bad: Loss vs. Richmond
Out for now
Butler: 16-7 (5-6), 68 RPI, 98 SoS, 209 non-conference SoS
The good: Win vs. Purdue
The bad: Loss vs. Marquette
Georgetown: 13-11 (6-5), 73 RPI, 21 SoS, 38 non-conference SoS
The good: Wins vs. Xavier, Syracuse
The bad: Losses vs. UNC-Asheville, Radford
Creighton: 15-9 (6-5), 101 RPI, 108 SoS, 286 non-conference SoS
The good: Win vs. Seton Hall
The bad: Loss vs. Loyola (Chicago)
- Locks: Iowa, Michigan State, Maryland
- Probable: Purdue
- Bubble: Michigan, Indiana, Wisconsin, Ohio State
In for now
Michigan: 16-7 (7-4), 54 RPI, 59 SoS, 117 non-conference SoS
The good: Wins vs. Maryland, Texas
The bad: No bad losses to date
Indiana: 19-5 (9-2), 55 RPI, 136 SoS, 213 non-conference SoS
The good: Win vs. Notre Dame
The bad: Losses vs. Penn State, UNLV
Out for now
Wisconsin: 14-9 (6-4), 65 RPI, 18 SoS, 46 non-conference SoS
The good: Wins vs. Michigan State, VCU, Syracuse
The bad: Losses vs. Marquette, Northwestern, Milwaukee, Western Illinois
Ohio State: 14-10 (6-5), 87 RPI, 52 SoS, 65 non-conference SoS
The good: Win vs. Kentucky
The bad: Losses vs. Texas-Arlington, Memphis, Louisiana Tech
- Locks: Oklahoma, Kansas, Iowa State, West Virginia, Texas
- Probable: Baylor
- Bubble: Kansas State, Texas Tech
In for now
Kansas State: 14-9 (3-7), 40 RPI, 7 SoS, 113 non-conference SoS
The good: Win vs. Oklahoma
The bad: No bad losses to date
Out for now
Texas Tech: 13-9 (3-7), 53 RPI, 8 SoS, 61 non-conference SoS
The good: Win vs. Texas
The bad: No bad losses to date
- Locks: Oregon, USC, Utah
- Probable: Arizona
- Bubble: Oregon State, California, Colorado, Washington, UCLA, Stanford, Arizona State
In for now
Oregon State: 13-8 (5-6), 42 RPI, 9 SoS, 86 non-conference SoS
The good: Wins vs. Oregon, USC, Utah, Colorado, California
The bad: No bad losses to date
California: 15-8 (5-5), 34 RPI, 24 SoS, 93 non-conference SoS
The good: Wins vs. Utah, Colorado, Arizona, Davidson
The bad: Loss to Richmond
Colorado: 16-7 (7-5), 26 RPI, 32 SoS, 107 non-conference SoS
The good: Wins vs. Oregon, California, Oregon State
The bad: No bad losses to date
Washington: 15-8 (7-4), 56 RPI, 30 SoS, 111 non-conference SoS
The good: Wins vs. USC, Texas, Colorado
The bad: Loss vs. Oakland
Out for now
UCLA: 13-10 (4-6), 72 RPI, 19 SoS, 42 non-conference SoS
The good: Wins vs. Kentucky, Arizona, Oregon State
The bad: Loss vs. Washington State
Stanford: 10-10 (4-6), 71 RPI, 1 SoS, 37 non-conference SoS
The good: Wins vs. Utah, California, Oregon State
The bad: No bad losses to date
Arizona State: 13-11 (3-8), 74 RPI, 23 SoS, 43 non-conference SoS
The good: Wins vs. Texas A&M, Oregon State
The bad: Losses vs. Sacramento State, Marquette
- Locks: Texas A&M, Kentucky
- Probable: South Carolina, Florida
- Bubble: LSU, Vanderbilt, Alabama, Georgia
In for now
LSU: 15-8 (8-2), 75 RPI, 83 SoS, 196 non-conference SoS
The good: Win vs. Kentucky
The bad: Losses vs. North Carolina State, Houston, Marquette
Out for now
Vanderbilt: 13-10 (5-5), 58 RPI, 14 SoS, 24 non-conference SoS
The good: Wins vs. Texas A&M, Florida
The bad: No bad losses to date
Alabama: 13-9 (4-6), 57 RPI, 26 SoS, 18 non-conference SoS
The good: Wins vs. South Carolina, Notre Dame, Wichita State
The bad: Loss vs. Auburn
Georgia: 13-8 (6-4), 66 RPI, 27 SoS, 8 non-conference SoS
The good: Win vs. South Carolina
The bad: No bad losses to date
*Assuming teams don't win their smaller conference tournaments and secure the automatic bid.
- Locks: N/A
- Probable: N/A
- Bubble: Wichita State, Monmouth, Gonzaga, St. Mary's, San Diego State, Valparaiso, Chattanooga
In for now
Wichita State: 16-6 (11-1), 32 RPI, 79 SoS, 6 non-conference SoS
The good: Win vs. Utah
The bad: Loss vs. Illinois State
Monmouth: 19-5 (11-2), 30 RPI, 122 SoS, 29 non-conference SoS
The good: Wins vs. USC, Notre Dame
The bad: Losses vs. Canisius, Army, Manhattan
Gonzaga: 18-5 (11-2), 62 RPI, 116 SoS, 49 non-conference SoS
The good: No top-50 RPI wins to date
The bad: No bad losses to date
St. Mary's: 18-3 (10-2), 52 RPI, 188 SoS, 214 non-conference SoS
The good: No top-50 RPI wins to date
The bad: Loss vs. Pepperdine
San Diego State: 16-6 (11-0), 44 RPI, 60 SoS, 11 non-conference SoS
The good: Win vs. California
The bad: Losses vs. Grand Canyon, San Diego
Out for now
Valparaiso: 18-4 (10-1), 46 RPI, 176 SoS, 45 non-conference SoS
The good: Win vs. Oregon State
The bad: Losses vs. Wright State, Ball State
Chattanooga: 19-3 (10-1), 37 RPI, 191 SoS, 159 non-conference SoS
***
Note: All RPI and statistical data is used from WarrenNolan.com.
About our bracketologist: Shelby Mast has been projecting the field since 2005 and has finished as one of the top 5 national bracketologists for his website, Bracket W.A.G. He’s predicted for The Indianapolis Star, collegeinsider.com and is an inaugural member of the Super 10 Selection Committee. Follow him on Twitter @BracketWag.