Advertisement

All-Star selections showcase MLB's incredible wealth of young talent

With the massive successes of Bryce Harper and Mike Trout in 2015 and a series of high-profile call-ups for players like Kris Bryant, Carlos Correa and Addison Russell, it sure seems like baseball has as exciting a crop of young talent as it has in years. Harper and Trout, after all, are both still among the game’s younger players: Trout won’t turn 24 until August, Harper will turn 23 in October.

But a closer look at the 2015 All-Star rosters, as announced Monday suggests that the 2015 version of the event will not feature an atypical number of young stars. Using players’ age-25 seasons as the benchmark for “young” — since that’s about the age they’re expected to slow their improvement and hit their primes — shows 19 young players combined on the National and American League All-Star teams to date, with a few in the mix for the final vote. There were 14 in 2014, 18 in 2013, 16 in 2012, and 18 in 2011. This season’s total is high, but it’s not extraordinarily high.

Here’s where it gets interesting: Though it will not feature a disproportionately high number of young players, the 2015 All-Star Game will feature more established young stars than ever before — at least if you base a player’s “stardom” on his number of All-Star selections.

Jose Altuve

Jose Altuve slides past Salvador Perez (PHOTO: Scott Halleran/Getty Images)

Eight players 25 or under will be returning to the All-Star Game for at least a second time in 2015. And in Trout, Harper, Jose Altuve, Madison Bumgarner, Salvador Perez and Giancarlo Stanton, this year boasts six players age 25 or younger who are now three-time All-Stars. That has never happened before.

The distinction, though somewhat arbitrary, is no small achievement. Before this season, only 74 guys in baseball history were three-time All-Stars before they turned 26. Of those eligible, 33 of 61 are in the Hall of Fame, and set of active players who did it includes Albert Pujols, Miguel Cabrera, Alex Rodriguez and Clayton Kershaw. It turns out you have to be really good to make the All-Star team three times by age 25.

An exhaustive — and exhausting — dive into BaseballCube.com’s collection of past All-Star rosters, dating back all the way to 1933, shows that no season before this one has ever seen as many young three-time All-Stars. In six different seasons, there were as many as four — most recently in 1986, with Don Mattingly, Dwight Gooden, Darryl Strawberry and Cal Ripken. Most Midsummer Classics featured zero or one.

(Getty Images)

(Getty Images)

And this season, again, has two more of those guys than any year before. It’s not an entirely fair comparison, of course, since there are more All-Stars now then there were in, say, 1970, when Catfish Hunter, Tom Seaver, Rod Carew and Johnny Bench were all on their third or fourth All-Star appearance before the age of 26. But the point stands: We don’t often see so many players this young and this good.

So the perception that MLB features an abundance of young talent in 2015 is not just that. Apologies if that seems obvious — anyone watching the sport this year probably could have guessed at it. There are always a lot of young players around the fringes of the All-Star rosters, but this season’s group will include an exciting crop of young superstars that few if any prior seasons can match.

It’s a cool thing, and it’s an exciting time to be watching baseball.

More MLB